Collin County District Attorney Greg Willis has responded to allegations raised by Mike Howard, the lead defense attorney in Karmelo Anthony's murder trial. Anthony is currently serving a 35-year sentence following his conviction for the murder of Austin Metcalf.
Howard's affidavit, which is part of Anthony's appeal, alleges that prosecutors violated a "gentlemen's agreement" intended to limit character evidence concerning Anthony and the Metcalfs. He also argues that a significant closed-door hearing was expedited, which he claims impaired the defense's ability to prepare.
Willis contends that court transcripts obtained by CBS News Texas refute many of Howard's assertions. He remarked that numerous claims do not align with the actual court proceedings. During a private meeting about Anthony's potential testimony, Howard confirmed that the agreement was maintained, while Judge John Roach Jr. made it clear he would not enforce informal agreements in a criminal matter.
Howard's affidavit indicates he believed Anthony would testify but claims the judge restricted their preparation time. However, the transcript reveals that the judge thoroughly explained Anthony's rights and allowed more than 30 minutes for the defense to deliberate, during which Anthony spoke with his parents before opting not to testify.
Willis expressed his surprise and disappointment regarding Howard's claims, emphasizing that the prosecution acted fairly and professionally throughout the case. Howard has not replied to requests for comment and will not engage in the forthcoming appeal. Willis anticipates that Anthony's appeal is likely to be rejected, affirming confidence in the prosecution's actions.
The initial hearing related to the appeal may take place as early as next month.
